
On Sunday, during a routine phone call with my younger sister, she asked me whether it was possible for me to obtain dual citizenship retroactively. What she meant was, would I be able to reclaim my German nationality which I had relinquished thirty years ago in a Federal building in Newark, NJ. The question stunned me, as I have not considered myself to be German in over three decades, long before I became an official American citizen. I asked her why she posed this question, and she said that she thought I might want to leave the United States ruled by President Trump, since the land of the free no longer appeared to be free and equal for all.
I was quite shocked but also saddened by her suggestion. To me, the United States of America has always stood for freedom and opportunity. Its flag shining as a beacon of light to all of the oppressed peoples across the world, or so I thought. As a historian, I am not blind to the struggles and shortcomings of American policies and its history. Yet, I have always been convinced that the good outweighed the bad; and that we, unlike other nations, were built on the unique foundation of our constitution, which has always been the means towards greater freedom and individual rights throughout the nation’s existence.
While, I have no plans to leave this country, and most certainly not for Germany, where both Communist and Fascist parties are on the ascendency and where Putin’s army stands dangerously close to its border, I was nonetheless compelled to give this issue more thought. I still believe that we can safeguard our nation’s identity, but we need to be vigilant and dedicated to the core mission of freedom and basic rights for every American. This is particularly crucial as our current government has made it its mission to undermine and weaken the constitution, the rule of law, our economic supremacy in the world, as well as our international standing among our allies and foes alike. Regardless of political party affiliation, no past president has so openly and aggressively disrespected what he has sworn to protect and uphold. The current attack on our country is not a matter of party politics, or what policy may or may not be more effective. Informed, rational human beings can discuss various points and positions and even agree to disagree yet still move forward to get the business of government done. Our system is built on collaboration, and shared power, as our founding fathers feared nothing more than tyranny of one faction over another, which is why set up our intricate system of checks and balances.
The current concentrated assault on our constitution is dangerously similar to the standard playbook used by any undemocratic dictator or oligarch, who has ever aimed to dismantle an open society. As Americans, we need to come together and save what makes us unique and strong: the freedom to choose how we want to live, the right to disagree and criticize the government (peacefully), and the pioneer spirit of innovation and confidence, the “can do” attitude that made America possible and desirable for over 400 years.
So, my dear sister, the answer is no — I shall never become a refugee from America, thank you though for the invitation. Rather than leave, I plan to do whatever is in my power, to ensure that America will remain the city on the hill, shining its beacon of light to a dark world, which is why I came here in the first place over 30 years ago. I trust I shall find many of my fellow Americans along the way, aiming for the same goal.
Christiane Warren, Ph.D.
Historian For Hire
October 27.2026

Comments